Best Chew Toys for Beagle Puppies – 2026 Reviews

Beagle puppies, like all puppies, go through a teething phase where their gums are sore and their instinct to chew is at an all-time high. Without an appropriate outlet, they’ll turn to whatever is within reach – shoes, furniture legs, electrical cords. A rotation of well-chosen chew toys not only protects your belongings but also helps with dental health and provides mental stimulation. For beagles, who are scent-driven and intelligent, toys with flavours or textures they can explore work especially well.

The material you choose makes all the difference in durability and safety. Nylon chews, like those from Benebone and Nylabone, are tough and long-lasting – ideal for persistent chewers. They don’t tear apart, but you’ll want to monitor wear and replace them once they become small enough to swallow. Rubber toys (TPR or natural rubber) offer more give and are often softer on gums, but they may not survive an aggressive chewer. Plush and fabric toys are great for cuddling and gentle play, but they’ll be destroyed quickly if your beagle puppy is a heavy chewer. Consider mixing materials: a durable nylon bone for solo chewing, a rubber tug toy for interactive play, and a plushie for comfort.

Chew toys that are too small pose a choking hazard, while those too large can frustrate a small jaw. For a beagle puppy, aim for toys labeled for small to medium breeds – typically with dimensions that are too big to swallow whole but still fit comfortably between the paws. Avoid any toy your puppy can fit entirely in their mouth. The paw-friendly shapes of Benebones, with their curved edges, make them easy for puppies to grab and hold, which is a big plus.

Beagles live by their noses, so a flavour-infused chew toy can be a powerful motivator. Benebone uses real bacon throughout the nylon, creating a scent and taste that lingers. Nylabone adds a mild chicken scent to its puppy bones. A toy that smells interesting is more likely to hold your puppy’s attention and redirect them from forbidden items. Just be aware that strong scents can be off-putting to humans; air the toy out if needed.

When beagle pups are deep in the teething trenches, a chilled chew can work wonders. Freezable toys like the Cool Teething Stick or the Pawaboo Cooling Set provide icy relief that numbs gums and distracts. They’re especially welcome on hot summer days. Just remember that these aren’t replacement for durable nylon chews – they’re a complementary tool. And always supervise, as frozen fabric or rubber may not hold up to determined gnawing.

Both brands produce excellent nylon chews, but they have key differences. Benebone infuses real bacon throughout, making them highly attractive to scent-driven beagles; the nylon is a touch softer than adult Nylabones but still very durable. Nylabone‘s puppy bones are gentler and often have raised bumps for gum massage, but the flavour is more subtle. If your puppy is a picky chewer, the Benebone 2-Pack is our top pick. If you want a softer introduction with a bonus edible treat, the Nylabone Starter Set is a thoughtful alternative.