Your Scottish Terrier puppy is in the thick of teething, and suddenly every shoe, chair leg, and stray sock looks like a chew toy. Their little jaws need relief, and without the right outlets, your belongings pay the price. The right chew toy can soothe sore gums, channel that chewing instinct, and save your sanity-but not every toy labelled “puppy” actually holds up to a determined little terrier.
Scottish Terriers may be small, but they’ve got a sturdy build and a surprisingly strong bite for their size. The best chew toys balance gentleness for tender teething gums with enough durability to satisfy a persistent chewer. We’ve combed through the top options across major brands to find toys that fit a Scottie pup’s mouth, stand up to their tenacity, and make teething more manageable.
Best Chew Toys for Scottish Terrier Puppies – 2026 Reviews
Puppy 4-Pack – Real Bacon Teething Chews
A set of four durable nylon chews infused with real bacon, sized perfectly for small puppies under 30 lbs. Made in the USA, these are a tad softer than adult Benebones for teething relief.
Puppy Starter Set – Gentle Chews & Treat
This kit includes a soft puppy bone, a teething chew toy, and a natural lamb & apple treat. Designed for pups up to 25 lbs, it’s a complete introduction to appropriate chewing.
Puppy 2-Pack Maplestick/Zaggler – Tiny Bacon Duo
Two tiny nylon chews in Maplestick and Zaggler shapes, both infused with real bacon and a hint of maplewood. Designed for gentle chewers under 30 lbs.
Cool Teething Stick – Freezable Gum Relief
A freezable fabric chew toy designed to soothe sore gums. The cotton-poly shell can be soaked and frozen for crunchy, cooling relief.
Crinkle Duck – No-Stuffing Soft Squeaky Toy
A soft plush duck with crinkle and squeaker sounds, designed with no stuffing to prevent mess. Lightweight and floppy, ideal for cuddly play.
Mini Bone Tug – Floppy Rubber Teething Chew
Three interlocking rubber bones that create a floppy chew toy with ridged surfaces to massage gums and clean teeth. Sized for small breeds.
How We Evaluated These Chew Toys for Scottish Terrier Puppies
We didn’t see these toys through a full teething phase with a litter of Scottish Terrier puppies. What we did: cross-referenced 6 chew toys from 4 distinct brands across 5 decision axes – teething relief, durability, size suitability, material safety, and engagement. We triangulated published specifications, aggregated owner feedback where available, and mapped each toy against the needs of a teething small-breed terrier.
The scoring framework weighted real-world puppy fit (60%) – how well each option delivers on gum soothing, chewing satisfaction, and safety for a Scottie pup – against feature differentiation (40%) – unique benefits like freezable relief, bacon flavour, or interactive play design. We have no commercial relationship with any of the brands featured; recommendations track fit and differentiation, not brand preference. If you’re looking for an all-around teething solution, the Puppy 4-Pack is our top pick; if you prefer a starter kit with a treat, the Nylabone Starter Set is a close runner-up.
How to Choose the Right Chew Toys for Scottish Terrier Puppies
Matching Chew Toys to Your Teething Puppy's Needs
Teething can start as early as 3 weeks and last until about 6 months, during which your puppy’s gums will be sore and they’ll want to chew almost constantly. The right toy not only relieves discomfort but also teaches appropriate chewing habits from the start. For a Scottish Terrier, choose toys specifically labelled for teething puppies – they’re made to be gentler on developing teeth and gums.
Nylon, Rubber, or Plush: Which Chew Toy Material Works Best?
Nylon chews, like those from Benebone and Nylabone, are durable and can satisfy a persistent chewer, but make sure they’re the puppy-specific versions to avoid being too hard. Rubber toys, such as the Petstages Mini Bone Tug, offer a bit of give and are great for interactive play. Plush toys like the Best Pet Supplies Crinkle Duck are soft and comforting but won’t stand up to heavy chewing – they’re best for supervised cuddle sessions. For a Scottie pup, a mix of materials often works best.
Sizing Chew Toys for Your Scottish Terrier's Small Mouth
Even though Scottish Terriers are sturdy for their size, their mouths are still small. Look for toys labelled tiny, small, or for breeds under 30 lbs. The Benebone Puppy 2-Pack in tiny is a perfect example – the shapes are easy for a little jaw to grab. Avoid anything that could be a choking hazard or that requires the puppy to open its mouth uncomfortably wide.
Durability vs. Softness: Finding the Balance
Teething toys need to be soft enough to soothe gums but durable enough to last more than a few days. The Benebone 4-Pack strikes this balance well with its slightly forgiving puppy nylon. In contrast, the Petstages Cool Teething Stick prioritizes soft relief over longevity and will tear quickly under determined chewing. Assess your puppy’s chewing intensity: if they’re already showing a strong bite, lean toward tougher nylon or rubber options.
Safety First: What to Avoid in Puppy Chew Toys
Always supervise your puppy with any chew toy, especially ones with squeakers or small parts that could be ingested. Avoid toys that are too hard – they can fracture young teeth. Check for loose threads, cracks, or pieces that might break off. The Petstages Mini Bone Tug has interlocking bones that should be inspected for wear, while the Nylabone Starter Set includes a treat that should be given under supervision. When in doubt, err on the side of caution.
Flavor and Engagement: Do Bacon-Scented Toys Really Help?
Infused flavours like the real bacon in Benebone toys can significantly increase a puppy’s interest, especially when they’re being introduced to a new chew. If your pup is picky, a scented toy might be the key to getting them to choose the right thing to chew. However, not all dogs respond to flavours, and some may lose interest over time. The Nylabone set includes a treat that can also be used to reward appropriate chewing.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the difference between the Benebone Puppy 4-Pack and the Petstages Cool Teething Stick?
The Benebone 4-Pack is a set of durable nylon chews that stand up to prolonged chewing and are infused with real bacon flavour. The Petstages Cool Teething Stick is a freezable fabric toy designed for short, soothing sessions – it’s softer and provides cold relief, but it won’t last as long. For a Scottish Terrier puppy that likes to chew a lot, the Benebone is better for daily use; the teething stick is great for occasional gum-soothing moments.
Are Benebone chew toys safe for a 10-week-old Scottish Terrier?
Yes, provided you choose the puppy line sized for small dogs (like the Benebone Puppy 4-Pack or the tiny 2-Pack). These are slightly softer than adult Benebones and have a paw-friendly design that’s easy for little mouths to grasp. Always supervise your puppy and check for any signs of wear. Because Scottish Terriers can be determined chewers, even a young pup might test the limits, so regular inspection is key.
How do I choose between the Nylabone Puppy Starter Set and the Benebone Puppy 2-Pack?
The Nylabone Starter Set includes a chew toy and a treat, making it ideal for introducing a puppy to chewing routines and rewarding good behaviour. The Benebone 2-Pack focuses entirely on chewing with two uniquely shaped, bacon-flavoured toys. If you want a multi-purpose kit with a treat, go Nylabone. If your priority is pure chewing satisfaction with a flavour punch, the Benebone 2-Pack at the tiny size is perfect for a Scottie pup.
Can Scottish Terrier puppies have plush toys like the Best Pet Supplies Crinkle Duck?
Yes, as long as you supervise. Plush toys like the Crinkle Duck are soft and engaging, with crinkle and squeak sounds that many puppies adore. However, a Scottish Terrier puppy with a strong chewing instinct may rip it open quickly. Use this type of toy for gentle play sessions rather than leaving it in the crate unsupervised. The no-stuffing design reduces mess, but it’s still a plush, not a primary teething chew.
How do I clean and maintain puppy chew toys?
Nylon toys like Benebone and Nylabone can be wiped down with a damp cloth or scrubbed with a little dish soap and water to remove drool and debris – just avoid soaking them. Rubber toys, like the Petstages Mini Bone Tug, can often be rinsed under warm water. Fabric toys, such as the Cool Teething Stick, should be hand-washed and air-dried. Regularly inspect all toys for cracking or fraying, and replace when they show signs of wear.
Final Verdict
For most Scottish Terrier puppies, the Benebone Puppy 4-Pack is the best overall – it nails durability and flavour while staying gentle on teething gums. If you want a kit that includes a treat and introduces good chewing habits right away, the Nylabone Puppy Starter Set is a close second. For short teething relief sessions, the Petstages Cool Teething Stick brings cooling comfort. Whichever you pick, remember that supervision and regular replacement are key to keeping your Scottie pup safe and satisfied. Happy chewing!